Thursday, May 14, 2015

More on Problems with the Police Report



The previous post (April 17, 2015) discussed the problematic redaction of the names of certain “friends and neighbors” of my brother whose statements are summarized or quoted in Inv. Kalfas’s narrative in the police report.  Those individuals who commented negatively about Mark’s drinking are thus provided anonymity, even though some of their remarks seem questionable.  Furthermore, it is difficult to comprehend who could have made such statements since virtually all of Mark’s neighbors told me that they were not interviewed by the State Police investigator.  This post considers redactions and problematic statements in the police report related to one specific individual, who was on the scene of Mark’s truck fire and gave a witness statement.

The relevant entry in Inv. Kalfas’s narrative is for 10/02/03 (see link near the top right for the police report).  It reads as follows: “Also this date, member met with and interviewed […redaction…] is a friend of the family and a […redaction…].  He was the third person on the scene the night of the fire.  His Supporting Deposition is attached as enclosure #6.”  Although the name is blacked out, a list on the following page (left, one assumes, inadvertently unredacted) identifies that enclosure as Mark Ward’s witness statement. 

The reference to Ward as “a friend of the family” raises questions.  Did Ward describe himself that way?  Or did Kalfas loosely paraphrase him?  In any case, it is not an accurate description.  Mark Ward was clearly not one of my brother’s friends.  I can’t say if he had any kind of relationship with Mark’s and Susan’s two children.  But as the superintendent of the Salamanca school system, where Susan was employed as a clerk in the accounting office, he did know her and was reportedly a close friend of hers. 

What is redacted after the phrase “friend of the family”?  The word “firefighter” would seem logically to fit in.  But why would that have been blacked out?  Ward’s witness statement itself is explicit about his role as a firefighter.  Were the State Police trying to keep something else about Ward secret?

 Inv. Kalfas’s reference to Ward as “the third person on the scene the night of the fire” is also incorrect.  The third person on the scene was in fact firefighter Gary Wind.  As Kalfas indicates in his entry for 10/10/03, the second person on the scene is identified through enclosure #7 as EMT Cheryl Simcox, who saw Mark’s wife Susan standing at the end of the driveway when she arrived on the scene.  By Kalfas’s own calculation, then, Ward was the fourth person on the scene.

Ward’s witness statement (see enclosure #6, after Kalfas’s narrative), taken on 10/10/03 (and handwritten), contains a redaction of almost a full line.  The relevant passage reads as follows: “On tuesday [sic], Sept. 23, 2003 at slightly before 11:00 pm my pager went off indicating a truck fire & possible entrapment at the Pavlock residence on t6 [unclear; see enc. #6] Whalen Rd.  This was not in my fire Dist. […redaction…] and I am within 2 minutes of her house[.]  I responded.”  What reason could there have been for blacking out that rather lengthy section?  In my interview with current Cattaraugus County District Attorney Lori Rieman back in May 2010, I asked that question.  D. A. Rieman replied that it had something to do with Ward’s job.  But Ward was the superintendent of the Salamanca school system and a volunteer firefighter, and his actions on the scene of the fire had no bearing on the need to protect special police investigative procedures.  Information about him should not have been kept secret.

In recounting what he did on the scene, Ward states that the truck was on fire “with the majority of it centered in the cab” and that when he asked “where Mark was, she [Susan? Or Cheryl?] pointed to the field.”  Observing that Mark “was still on fire,” Ward goes on to say that he “went to him and he appeared to be dead but [...redaction of name.., presumably Gary Wind] looked and saw that he was breathing.”  After mentioning that he retrieved coats from his vehicle and put out the rest of the fire, Ward says that Mark “was able to talk–we asked him what happened, and twice he mentioned a gasoline can but these were the only words I could understand.” 

Ward’s statement that Mark “was able to talk” certainly cannot be taken at face value but must be understood only with the qualifiers that follow in Ward’s account.  He makes it clear that he could understand only two words, “gasoline can,” which he says he heard Mark utter twice.  In his own witness statement, Gary Wind, who was there shortly before, and with, Mark Ward says that he could understand only the word “gas.”  Wayne Frank, who told me that he arrived right after Ward, insisted that he could understand nothing that my brother was trying to say (see post of November 30, 2011). 

It is unfortunate that Ward was not more careful in his choice of language because the State Police and the District Attorney’s office later insisted that emergency workers found Mark “able to talk.”  But one firefighter insisted orally that nothing Mark had been trying to say was comprehensible, and the other two heard rather different things, “gas” versus “gasoline can.”

What do those phrases really mean in the context of a man lying near death, after suffering third- degree burns over ninety percent of his body, including his entire head?  They certainly do not substantiate the claim by the State Police and the District Attorney’s office that Mark was eliminating foul play in the fire that had severely burned him and left him on the brink of death.  It was clear to Gary Wind and Wayne Frank that Mark was trying to communicate something to them.  One cannot rule out the possibility that he was attempting to explain that someone had poured gasoline on him and set him on fire. 

It is also a matter of concern that Ward reportedly said something else to another emergency worker.  When I spoke with Mark’s neighbor and EMT Cheryl Simcox in May 2006, I asked if she had heard Mark say anything.  Cheryl replied that she had remained with Susan as firefighters arrived but added that Mark Ward had mentioned hearing my brother say something like "I didn't do anything."  I was concerned about Cheryl’s information since Ward does not report anything like that in his witness statement but, as mentioned above, says that he could understand only the words “gasoline can” and nothing more. 

Mark’s wife Susan, however, did claim that Mark had said virtually those same words to her (see post of November 30, 2011).  Here is what Susan says verbatim in her witness statement: “I tried to put the flames on him out.  I asked him What did you do and he said, ‘I did nothing.’”  Cheryl Simcox similarly records in her own witness statement what Susan told her: she went over to Mark and asked him, "What did you do?  My God, what did you do?" and he replied, "I did nothing." 

It would appear that Ward in his comment to Cheryl was simply echoing Susan’s own words.  Could Mr. Ward have made the same statement to others that he reportedly made to Cheryl?  The claim that Mark said he didn’t do anything is highly problematic in light of the investigating authorities’ insistence that Mark was able to speak to emergency workers and said nothing about foul play.   My brother lost his life in a very suspicious truck fire, yet the State Police investigators never even considered murder and glossed over almost every piece of evidence that did not conform to a pre-conceived theory of accident or suicide.

At the end of his witness statement, Ward says the following: “Sue was holding a sweatshirt (white) that she said she had used to try to put Mark out (fire).”  Ward here appears to accept–but certainly does not contest--Susan’s claim that she used her white sweatshirt to bat out the flames on Mark.  That is also problematic in light of statements by other eyewitnesses who observed that Susan’s white sweatshirt was completely clean, with no burn marks or soot on it.  Cheryl Simcox makes that clear in her witness statement.  At least one other person on the scene of the fire expressed concern orally about Susan’s claim, and at the burn unit the following morning Carol McKenna also noticed that Susan’s white sweatshirt was clean, with no burn marks.  But only Cheryl Simcox’s and Mark Ward’s statements are part of the formal record in the police report.

Susan’s claim about using that white sweatshirt, along with other questionable statements she made (see esp. posts of August 22 and September 22, 2012), should have been pursued by the State Police investigators.  It is a matter of concern that even within the past couple of years, as reported by my nephew (see post of November 23, 2103), Susan told Carol McKenna that Mark had left a suicide letter, contradicting her official statement to Inv. Kalfas that there was no suicide letter (recorded as an entry in the police report for 12/12/03).

Clearly, both Ward and his wife have been close to Susan.  When I phoned the relatives’ lounge at the burn unit late in the morning after the fire and my brother’s house late that afternoon to find out how Mark could have got so badly burned, in each case a friend of Susan’s answered the phone.  Although she did not identify herself, one of those two friends informed me that she was a neighbor and a friend of Susan's.  She added that she and her husband had seen the flames of the truck fire from their house and that he had been one of the first emergency workers on the scene.  This woman was obviously Mark Ward’s wife Barbara. 

When I mentioned to a number of people from the Great Valley area that the Wards had seen the flames from their house, I was told that it would not have been possible for them to do so since their house was not close by and the land slopes down toward their direction.  An online search showed the Wards’ house to be 2.4 miles from Mark’s house.  That seems like too considerable a distance, especially downhill, for the Wards to have been able to see the flames from Mark’s burning truck. 

Given such a situation in which there was a potential conflict of interest, it is inexcusable that Inv. Kalfas did not ask the third firefighter on the scene, Wayne Frank, to give a witness statement.  Furthermore, as Cheryl Simcox informed me, Kalfas did not question her fully, and she did not know how far to go when he took her witness statement.  Complete information about what was observed on the scene of Mark’s truck fire was not sought and was certainly not obtained. 

Friday, April 17, 2015

Problematic Redactions in the Police Report


The police report on the investigation into my brother Mark’s death raises more questions than it answers.  (For the police report, see the link at the top right.)   Previous posts have referred to the problem of redactions in the report. In the copy that I received through a FOIL request, not only the names of individuals who were interviewed but also items of information related to those interviews are blacked out.  To judge by a letter to me from N. Y. State Police official Sandra Croote in 2004, information related to “non-routine police techniques and procedures” is kept confidential.  However, as Atty. Tony Tanke pointed out, individuals who give information in police investigations of this kind should not be entitled to anonymity or privacy about their statements.

Two entries for 9/25/03 on comments by Holy Cross Athletic Club members illustrate the problem not only of names redacted but also of significant misinformation included by the investigator.  The first reads, “Member interviewed [ . . .three-inch reaction . . .] at the Holy Cross Club, Salamanca.  They stated that the victim had been in the day before the fire and was acting ‘strange’ and ‘not like himself.’”  What specifically was this “strange” behavior that showed Mark “not like himself”?  Kalfas’s report of insinuations that Mark’s behavior at the club the day before the truck fire was somehow odd and inappropriate seems especially disingenuous because the investigator makes no mention in the entry for 9/25/03 (or elsewhere in the report) of the heated personal argument between my brother and Salamanca police officer Mark Marowski that very day at the Holy Cross Club and of Marowski’s call to the Salamanca police to arrest Mark on his way home to Great Valley.

I won’t reiterate here the problem of Marowski’s own heavy drinking (reportedly on that day, as usual, at the Holy Cross Club) or the report that Marowski was having an affair with my brother’s wife Susan (see posts of August 11, September 14, October 17, and December 14, 2014; January 16 and February 17, 2015).  But in light of Kalfas’s suppression of any reference to the quarrel between my brother and Ofc. Marowski, the redaction of the names of the Holy Cross Club members who made those statements about my brother’s behavior is outrageous.  It is all the more troubling in that no one who was at the Holy Cross Club that day has been willing to admit to being there (see post of November 16, 2014), despite efforts by me and others to find out.

A number of reasonable inferences can be drawn: (1) the individuals who made those statements are unwilling to stand by them; (2) Kalfas did not record their statements accurately; or (3) these individuals are afraid of the consequences of telling the full truth about what really went on at the Holy Cross Club that day between my brother and Ofc. Marowski and what they observed when Marowski made the phone call to the Salamanca police and apparently a call to someone else immediately afterward (on the latter, see April 8, 2013, and October 17, 2014).  On the possible third inference, it is understandable that people would be afraid of retaliation if they revealed damaging information about a police officer, especially when it is clear that the investigating authorities, in this case the New York State Police, did not want the local police officer implicated in any way in their investigation into a suspicious death.  But, then, what happens to justice?

The second entry for 9/25/03 on comments by Holy Cross Athletic Club members reads as follows: “Member interviewed numerous Holy Cross Athletic Club members who were all in agreement that the victim had been behaving unusually and was very upset about getting arrested for DWI the day before the fire.”  Here, there are two problems.  First, although there is no redaction per se, Kalfas’s failure to mention specifically who these “numerous Holy Cross Athletic Club members” were functions in a similar vein: the individuals who reported information about Mark’s allegedly precarious state of mind are given anonymity.  Second, and far more troubling, this information is inaccurate.

As pointed out previously, the truck fire was the day after my brother’s argument with Marowski and his subsequent DWI, and Kalfas acknowledged to Atty. Michael Kelly in 2005 that he could not find anyone who had seen Mark out the day of the truck fire (see September 22, 2010).  In addition, Mark did not go back to the Holy Cross Club after his DWI the day before but rather, according to his friend Todd Lindell, remained at Todd’s house in the evening after his release from his arrest.  Therefore, Holy Cross Club members could not have been able to comment on Mark’s state of mind following his DWI arrest.  Atty. Kelly surmised that Kalfas was perhaps referring to Mark’s feelings about his son Brian’s DWI (rather than his own) a week earlier.  Was Kalfas’s entry here the result of sloppy record keeping, or was it intentional?

A redaction in an entry for 10/25/03 is also troubling.  The relevant entry reads as follows: “Member interviewed [ . . .redaction of the specific names . . .].  The three are friends and neighbors of the victim. Each agreed that the victim used to hang around their residences a lot and was often drinking.”  The redaction of the three names here is problematic because it is very unclear who these individuals (“friends and neighbors”) could possibly be.  I asked virtually all of Mark’s neighbors, including those with connections to my brother, if they had been questioned by the State Police investigator and was told without exception that they had not been interviewed.

Two of these neighbors, Dan Smith and Eugene Woodworth, are themselves problematic because of statements they made about the scene of the fire (see posts of April 20 and November 30, 2011). Smith was certainly not a friend of my brother’s, but Woodworth had at least known Mark for a long time, since they had both worked on the railroad.  Smith and Woodworth explicitly stated to me that they had not been interviewed by the State Police investigator.  Neighbor Cheryl Simcox’s witness statement is in the police report: it says nothing about Mark’s drinking.

More recently, I contacted Mark’s neighbors Marilyn Siperek, Mary Ellen Collins, and Christine Rinko and was told in each case that they had not been questioned by the State Police investigator. Mrs. Collins and Mrs. Rinko were clear that their husbands had also not been questioned.  The neighbor next to the Rinkos said that he had not lived there when Mark was killed and that he bought the house from a local police officer named Drew Rozler (apparently a deputy sheriff), who I was later told was not actually living there at the time.  I did not have the opportunity to ask Shawn Gregory, a deputy sheriff who lives on Whalen Rd. (Mark’s street), if he was interviewed, but this much younger man was not known to be a friend of my brother’s.  Nor did I ask Peter Rapacioli’s daughter and son-in-law (brother of a veteran Salamanca police officer) if they were interviewed, though they too were certainly not friends of my brother’s.

One individual who lived in the general neighborhood, on the road parallel to Whalen Rd., but a bit farther away, was in fact a long-time friend of my brother’s and even served as a pall bearer at his funeral.  But when I recently asked now-retired deputy sheriff Sidney Lindell if he had been interviewed, he stated clearly that he had not.  Mark’s friend Todd Lindell also lived in the same area, on or near the same road as his cousin Sidney.  When I spoke to Todd in November 2003, he did not indicate that he had been interviewed.

Although I had been led to believe that the State Police investigator had questioned most of the neighbors, that does not appear to be the case, according to what these neighbors told me.  Kalfas himself stated to me in October 2003 that he was interviewing my brother’s friends to obtain relevant information.  But if that is the case, how is it that he did not learn the identity of the neighbor (and presumably friend) whom Mark was visiting immediately before the fire (see post of August 11, 2014)?  Could that person have failed to mention such significant pieces of information as Mark’s whereabouts right before the fire and his lack of any noticeable intoxication?

This post by no means exhausts the problems of the police report on Mark’s death.  But, at the very least, it is certainly clear that Inv. Kalfas made an effort to cast my brother in a negative light and to keep Ofc. Mark Marowski, well known as an alcoholic and an unscrupulous individual, out of the picture.  The police report on my brother’s death is not just sloppy.  It is insidious.

Tuesday, March 17, 2015

More about Police Protecting Their Own


This post considers the issue of police protecting their own in the investigation into my brother Mark’s death.  Salamanca police officer Mark Marowski was never investigated for his role in getting my brother arrested for DWI after their personal argument at the Holy Cross Club the very day before Mark’s suspicious death.  Yet Marowski’s serious problems with alcohol, gambling, and dependence on prescription drugs as well as his hostility toward my brother were well known, and according to information recently relayed to me, Marowski was having an affair with my brother’s wife Susan. (On Marowski, see posts of August 14, September 14, October 17, November 16, and December 14, 2014.)

There appears to have been a similarly cavalier attitude toward Peter Rapacioli, whose son-in-law is the brother of a veteran Salamanca police officer.  (On Rapacioli, see posts of May 15, June 26, and December 24, 2013, and April 19, 2014.)  In an entry in the police report (for September 25, 2003, with the name redacted), Rapacioli claims that he called to speak with Mark about a football pool but, not finding him home, spoke with my brother’s wife (in a conversation that allegedly lasted for about half an hour).
  
That (alleged) conversation took place immediately before Mark’s truck suspiciously went up in flames in the field across from their house.  As the State Police investigators were well aware, my brother and his wife had not been getting along at all for some time and were about to get divorced.  The State Police also knew about allegations that Rapacioli himself had been having an affair with Mark’s wife.  Yet they never checked the telephone records and refused to check them when requested to do so several times after the investigation was over.

According to Rapacioli (who called in June 2013 to berate me for mentioning him on my blog), he had been interviewed several times by the State Police during the investigation into my brother’s death.  Yet the police report mentions only the one interview with Rapacioli, at the very beginning of the investigation.  The police report entry makes it appear that Rapacioli was simply asked to verify the (alleged) call and to give his view as to whether Mark himself might have caused the truck fire.

Why aren’t the other interviews alluded to by Rapacioli recorded in the police report?  In my telephone conversation with him last August, Troop A Captain Steven Nigrelli stated that Cattaraugus County D. A. Edward Sharkey had known about the (alleged) phone call between Rapacioli and Mark’s wife Susan and that Sharkey insisted the case be closed.  Capt. Nigrelli also said that the State Police cannot obtain telephone records.  Yet Sr. Inv. John Wolfe told me back in 2005 that he would get the phone records if the case were re-opened.

A recent post (January 16, 2015) discusses the e-mail sent to me by Capt. Nigrelli summarizing the results of the inquiries and interviews that he asked State Police BCI staff to carry out as a result of our conversation last August.  As pointed out in that post, the summaries of the three interviews are highly problematic.  The one concerning Mark Marowski does not appear to represent any serious effort to determine if that now-retired police officer was in fact having an affair with my brother’s wife and if he was involved in Mark’s death.  The other two summaries do not accurately reflect the actual statements and information relayed to the BCI interviewer.  These interviews, as summarized in Capt. Nigrelli’s e-mail, look merely like "window dressing."

Capt. Nigrelli’s e-mail’s does not identify who this BCI interviewer was or indicate if there was more than one BCI interviewer.  But I have been led to believe that Sr. Inv. Christopher Iwankow conducted the interviews.  If so, that adds another problematic element to the investigation into Mark’s death.  According to the police report entry for September 25, 2003, “Investigator Christopher Iwanko [sic] attends the autopsy, taking photographs, fingerprints and a blood kit from the victim.” Iwankow thus had a role in the investigation into Mark’s death from the beginning.

What concerns me here about Sr. Inv. Iwankow is his response to an individual who called the State Police office in western New York in an effort to help me get the photos of the scene of Mark’s truck fire through a FOIL request.  In May 2011, independent criminologist Will Savive informed me by e-mail that he had spoken with a State Police official named Iwankow, who told him that they usually purge the records after five years.  Will added, “Oddly enough, he remembered the case.”

Shortly afterward, I spoke with Will by phone and let him know that according to the police report Iwankow had attended Mark's autopsy.  He then told me that at the end of their phone conversation he asked the State Police official for his name in case he had any follow-up questions.  But with my information about Iwankow’s connection to the investigation, Will was very concerned about how that State Police official had reacted to the request for his name.  According to Will, Iwankow did not reply at once, but instead hesitated for a good twenty seconds before identifying himself.  Why was Iwankow so reluctant to reveal his name?  Would any police official who had participated in an honest investigation have reacted in such a manner?

After filing a complaint about the investigation into Mark’s death with the U. S. Attorney’s office in Buffalo in 2004, I was advised to speak with the FBI agent in Jamestown.  In my first conversation with him, Agent Brent Isaacson stated that, although it wasn’t fair, the police are given the benefit of the doubt in controversial matters of this type.   But how far does such leeway extend?  Where is justice when the police are allowed to cover up the brutal murder of a decent man like my brother, who was doused with gasoline and burned to death?