Saturday, November 30, 2019

The Insistence of the New York State Police about Suicide


This post deals with the insistence by the New York State Police, from early in the investigation, that my brother had committed suicide.  In spite of the suspicious circumstances of Mark’s truck fire and then Cattaraugus County District Attorney Edward Sharkey’s conclusion in December 2003 (see police report) that there was no evidence of a suicide (or murder), the State Police continued to express their belief that my brother’s death was a suicide.

As mentioned previously, Mark's daughter Christie told me in a phone conversation the very night of his death that her father had committed suicide and left her a suicide note but that she was not telling others in order to protect the insurance money.  However, she denied knowing anything about a suicide letter to the lead investigator on the case, Edward Kalfas (see most recently post of March 31, 2019).  Although at that time I was not aware of what others had heard from any official sources, a nephew later informed me that Calla Smith, a sister of Mark’s wife, had told him in the week after Mark died that it looked as though they were going to rule his death a suicide.

According to my nephew, Calla Smith did not specify who had relayed that information but indicated that insurance companies would pay out even if the death was ruled a suicide.  As the investigation proceeded, Mark’s and my half-sister Carol McKenna also mentioned that Inv. Kalfas thought Mark’s death a suicide.  In my one face-to-face interview with him, Kalfas told me that it was “looking more and more like a suicide” but did not offer any explanation for that view.

Although the record of a high serum-alcohol level in Mark’s autopsy report might well have caused the investigating authorities to consider the possibility of suicide initially, there clearly was no sound basis for drawing such a conclusion.  As recorded in the police report, D.A. Sharkey denied evidence of a suicide or of a murder and stated that Mark’s death would be declared an accident, in spite of the suspicious circumstances, including the pool of Mark’s blood in his driveway, the gas can in the cab of his truck where he never put gas cans, and the wound to his forehead.

The “evidence” that the State Police offered when questioned about their views in subsequent years points to the lack of a serious investigation.  In late 2005, Sr. Inv. John Wolfe, who had replaced John Ensell in that position, insisted that Mark must have driven his truck into the field across from his house the night of the fire.  He would not even entertain the possibility that my brother, who had left a pool of blood in his driveway and had evidence of head wounds, could have been placed in his truck by his attackers, even though only the passenger’s side door was found open when emergency workers arrived at the scene.  In addition, he denied evidence of wounds to Mark’s head, which had in fact been observed on the scene and at the burn unit.

In early 2006, when Atty. Michael Kelly tried to get the case re-opened, Wolfe stated that he believed Mark’s death a suicide, though admitting that he could not rule out a homicide.  Apparently, he did not consider it an accident.  When Kelly brought up the subject of the head wounds, Wolfe did not acknowledge any real wounds, but claimed that what was on Mark had been caused by "positioning."   When I asked Kelly what Wolfe meant by "positioning," he explained that Mark could have been hit on the head when they placed him in the ambulance.  It seems difficult to believe that emergency personnel trying to help save a critically injured individual would carelessly cause any kind of damage to that person’s head.

In a telephone conversation with me in early 2006, Capt. George Brown rejected all of my concerns about the investigation.  He insisted that the police investigation and subsequent follow-up efforts pointed to either an accident or a suicide but they considered Mark’s death a suicide.  Like Wolfe, he insisted that that Mark had driven his truck into the field, most likely to move it away from the property in an effort to commit suicide.  How, then, did Mark’s blood end up in his driveway?

Brown also claimed that my brother had saturated himself with gas as part of his suicide plan.  How, then, did gasoline get on my brother’s head, especially since the State Police claimed that he was in the driver’s seat?  According to the fire investigator’s report, an accelerant (presumably gasoline) had started the fire in the area of the driver’s seat.  But Mark would have had to pour gasoline on his head with that gas can found in the truck from a standing position outside the truck.  Yet no evidence of a gasoline spill in that area is reported in either the fire investigator’s or the police report.

In spring 2010, I had a face-to-face interview with current Cattaraugus County District Attorney Lori Rieman and John Ensell, the Senior Investigator during Mark’s case but at that time an investigator in the D.A.’s office (see posts of March 23 and April 20, 2011).  I brought up the troubling circumstances of Mark’s arrest for DWI after off-duty police officer Mark Marowski, a highly problematic individual (see most recently the post of August 11, 2014), got into a heated personal argument with him at a local club and then called in to the Salamanca police to pick him up.  Ensell then claimed that Mark was so upset about getting the DWI that while he was in jail, they had him on a suicide watch.  That assertion immediately seemed disingenuous.  When I later mentioned it to another individual in law enforcement, he dismissed that claim, noting that the suicide watch is standard procedure in arrests there.

Since there were really no substantive grounds for the position of the State Police that my brother committed suicide, why have they continued to insist on it?  Clearly, if they acknowledged that Mark, with head wounds and the blood he shed in his driveway, was in no condition to back his truck into that field, then neither accident nor suicide would be a possibility.














Thursday, October 31, 2019

More on Problems with the Scene of My Brother’s Truck Fire


This post further considers problems with the scene of my brother’s truck fire.  It examines these two specific issues: why Mark would have been crawling away from the truck on the passenger’s rather than the driver’s side of the vehicle and how articles of Mark’s clothing ended up burning about sixty feet from the truck.

It is difficult to believe that Mark tried to escape from his burning truck on the passenger’s side, since only the driver’s side door was found open.  If, as the New York State Police investigators insisted, my brother had backed his truck down the driveway and parked it in the field, surely once the truck burst into flames, he would have quickly tried to get as far away from the vehicle as possible.  He would not have gone around the truck to the passenger’s side but would have proceeded away from the truck directly opposite the driver’s door, especially to avoid injury from an explosion potentially caused by the gas can inside the truck (on the suspicious circumstances of the gas can in the cab of the truck, see esp. post of October 30, 2018).

Furthermore, Mark was on fire himself when he was discovered, first by his wife Susan, then by neighbor and EMT Cheryl Simcox, and finally by the three firefighters Gary Wind, Mark Ward, and Wayne Frank, all within a period of a few minutes.  (See the witness statements of the first four. Oddly, Wayne was not asked to give a witness statement, but told me orally that he had helped to put the flames out on Mark.)  Since Cheryl Simcox’s house faces the field on Cross Rd., which intersects Whalen Rd. close to Mark’s house, she was able to get there within a couple of minutes.  The photo below, showing Whalen Road and the field from the front of Mark’s property to the intersection of Cross Road, with Cheryl Simcox’s house (set back) on the far right, indicates how close she was to the scene of the fire.



As Cheryl informed me, there were two-foot flames shooting from Mark’s body when she rushed to the scene almost immediately after she heard Kill Buck VFD being toned out at 10:55 p.m. for a vehicle fire on Whalen Road.  My brother’s burns were so severe that his attending physician at the burn unit of the Erie County Medical Center in Buffalo, Dr. Edward Piotrowski, exclaimed that he had never seen anyone come with such severe burns and wondered how that could have happened.  According to the doctor, Mark’s burns covered close to 90% of his body; almost all were third degree, with even some fourth degree, which he referred to as “charring.”  As that experienced burn specialist stated, even if Mark had caused a fire by lighting a cigarette with an open gas can in the truck, it still would not have saturated him with gasoline and caused such severe burns.  In his view, gasoline had to have been poured over Mark’s body.

Articles of Mark’s clothing observed burning about sixty feet from the truck also suggest that he was not in the truck when the fire started.  In his witness statement, Gary Wind refers to observing “two small spots” on fire about 60 feet from the truck; he later confirmed orally that the two spots were Mark’s clothes burning close to where he lay (see posts of February 2, 2012, and May 31, 2019).  My brother presumably had tried to save himself by pulling at least some of his burning clothes off.  In her witness statement, Mark’s wife Susan says that after rushing out of the house, she saw Mark crawling away from the truck and tried to bat the flames out on him with her white sweatshirt (on the issue of the lack of burn marks on that white sweatshirt, see esp. post of November 30, 2018) but mentions nothing about seeing any clothes on fire near Mark’s body.

Susan apparently did not leave the scene but was standing at the end of the driveway when Cheryl arrived.  At that point my brother had two-foot flames shooting from his entire body, and Cheryl informed me that Mark was lying on the ground and not moving.  Since the two small piles of burning clothes were about sixty feet from the truck, my brother couldn’t have been just crawling from the truck when he presumably threw them off.  So when did Mark pull those clothes off?

The New York State Police investigators should have tried to resolve the underlying discrepancy between Gary Wind’s and Susan’s statements in order to clarify the issue of Mark’s clothing burning on the ground so far from the truck and to find out what really happened that night.  Did they even bother to ask Gary Wind what those two “spots” on fire were?

Sunday, September 29, 2019

More on My Brother’s Whereabouts the Day of His Truck Fire


This post revisits the issue of my brother Mark’s whereabouts the day of his truck fire, considering specifically individuals who mentioned their failure reach him by phone or to see him that day.  The only formally documented information about Mark’s whereabouts the day of the truck fire is recorded in his wife Susan’s witness statement (see the link at the top right for “police report”).  There, Susan says that Mark was at home in the afternoon “slightly intoxicated,” that they had been watching television in the early evening, and that he left the house about 8:45 p.m. to go to “downtown Salamanca.”

Alexis Wright informed me that her husband Jim, a friend of my brother’s, could not reach Mark when he called that day but added that when they drove by about 5:30 p.m., they noticed his truck parked by the house (presumably in the usual area off the middle of the long driveway).  However, they did not see Mark himself or go to the house (see posts of August 22, 2012, and March 3, 2014, for Susan’s response to Mark when Alexis and Jim Wright drove him home from his DWI arrest the day before).

Mark’s friend Jim Poole informed me that my brother had returned a call from him the previous evening (the day of his DWI), leaving a message that he would explain why he hadn’t come over to help him paint that day, but he said that Mark never got back to him.  Jim explained that he then called my brother’s house the next day (the day of the fire) to speak with Mark directly, but again got no answer.

It is unclear why there was no answer when both Jim Wright and Jim Poole called Mark’s house that day.  It would certainly be very unusual for my brother not to answer the phone when he was home (see also post of March 3, 2014, on comments that Mark had been locked out of the house on several occasions).

Mark’s acquaintance Pete Rapacioli told me just weeks after Mark’s death that he had called, but failed to reach, Mark early on the day of the fire.  He indicated that he had been expecting to get Mark’s results from a football pool in order to determine the winner.  However, in a phone call to me in June 2013 to protest about being mentioned on this blog, he insisted that he had tried numerous times “throughout the day” to speak with Mark by phone but could not reach him.  Which was it: once or numerous times?

Furthermore, in that call to me in 2013, Rapacioli also stated that no one had seen Mark the entire day of the truck fire.  Yet he also said that he had been on the phone with my brother’s wife Susan, having a conversation that, according to her witness statement, lasted from about 10:30 to 11 p.m.  It seems very odd that Susan would not have mentioned that Mark had been at home with her for much of the afternoon and early evening, especially given Rapacioli’s stated insistence that he had tried to reach my brother so many times that day but could not reach him.

As mentioned previously on this blog (see esp. posts of December 27, 2012; May 13, 2013; and April 30, 2019), that alleged phone call between Mark’s wife and Pete Rapacioli was never verified by the N.Y. State Police investigators.  When later requested to check the phone records for that alleged call by Atty. Michael Kelly, Senior Investigator John Wolfe refused to do it.  As Kelly observed, given the circumstances of Mark’s death, that was basic police procedure and should have been done.  What possible motive could the State Police investigators have had for not checking those records?








Saturday, August 31, 2019

More on the Issue of Mark’s Blood Alcohol Level


This post raises questions about the blood alcohol level that authorities emphasized as a primary factor in my brother Mark’s death.  According to New York State Police investigators, because he was said to have had an extremely high blood alcohol level, Mark caused the fire that claimed his life by spilling gasoline inside his truck, either accidentally or deliberately, and then lighting a cigarette.

Two previous posts (September 1 and October 29, 2013) have discussed problems with the N.Y. State Police theory about how Mark’s truck came to be fifty feet into the field across from his house the night of the fire.  Tire tracks observed by emergency workers on the scene indicated that the truck went down the long driveway in a straight line and then into the field across the road.  The State Police insisted that Mark could have backed his truck straight down that driveway and fifty feet into the field even with an approximately .46 blood alcohol level (calculated from a .25 post-mortem serum alcohol level).

However, the police record for his DWI the day before contradicts that assumption.  According to the DWI report, Mark, with a .28 blood alcohol level, was “weaving back and forth in [the] lane” and “failed to keep right.”  With any higher blood alcohol level, then, he would at least have been weaving back and forth; with a .46, he could not possibly have driven the truck in a straight line.  In fact, if he really had a .46 blood alcohol level, my brother would almost certainly have been in a coma, if not actually dead.  Moreover, he had head wounds, including evidence of a blow to his forehead (see esp. post of January 29, 2019), that would have made driving his truck to any extent whatsoever virtually impossible.  Someone else had to have backed that truck into the field.

Mark’s attending physician at the burn unit insisted to me that the .25 post-mortem serum alcohol level recorded in the autopsy report (=.46 blood alcohol level at the time of the truck fire) had to be wrong.  A forensic toxicologist whom I consulted agreed with Mark’s attending physician that the .25 post-mortem serum alcohol level was hard to believe and outlined the scientific bases for that conclusion (see post of September 1, 2013).  He also added that lab technicians frequently make mistakes in recording blood alcohol levels, often reversing digits.  (There was an obvious sloppy mistake in the autopsy report, which records Mark’s height as 5 ft. 7 ½ in. instead of 5 ft. 11 ½ in.)   Furthermore, as previously mentioned (see esp. post of August 11, 2014), an anonymous letter sent to me revealed that shortly before the fire Mark had been at the house of a neighbor, who insisted that he could not have been so intoxicated as the authorities claimed.

It is also relevant that Mark’s wife Susan says in her witness statement that shortly before the fire she heard “a noise” in the garage that she thought was from the cats but later realized that Mark had taken a gas can out of the garage (see the police report by the link on the side of the blog).  It is difficult to understand how Mark’s wife could have known about the gas can right after the fire (see post of September 29, 2018).  But the State Police investigators clearly did not pursue the implications of those comments, which Susan made the night of the fire. 

If Mark had a .46 blood alcohol level, it seems impossible that he could have gone through the garage door by the side of the house (see photos by the link on the side of the blog) and walked through that space without stumbling and bumping into objects, making a lot of noise in the process.  As the arrest report for his DWI the day before indicates, Mark with a .28 blood alcohol level exhibited poor motor control and failed a variety of sobriety field tests, including “walk and turn,” “one leg stand,” and “finger to nose.”  Thus, if he was even more intoxicated the night of the fire, his wife would presumably have checked to see what was going on and would have reported much more than hearing a simple noise in the garage.

The New York State Police investigators, of course, knew about Mark’s DWI the day before the fire.  They were also aware of the highly problematic circumstances leading up to that DWI (see esp. posts of April 18, 2013, September 14, 2014, and June 21, 2016).  In particular, after being involved in a personal argument with my brother at a local club, off-duty police officer Mark Marowski called in to the Salamanca police to pick Mark up for DWI on his way home.  Marowski and my brother had reportedly got into arguments at that club on multiple occasions.  It was also well known that Marowski had serious problems with both drugs and alcohol (and, ironically, was later picked up for DWI himself).

It is troubling that apparently nothing was done to investigate Marowski himself for possible involvement in the events that ended in the suspicious truck fire that took my brother’s life.  The claim of an affair between Marowski and Mark’s wife (see post of August 11, 2014) makes that failure seem all the more like an example of police protecting other police.  Who else might the police have been protecting?

Wednesday, July 31, 2019

More on the Alleged Suicide Letter in the Deaths of Mark and Dale Tarapacki


Previous posts have brought up the issue of a suicide letter allegedly left by my brother Mark (see September 22, 2010; November 23, 2013; January 31, 2018; and March 31, 2019).  In addition, the post of January 31, 2018, refers to a report by two individuals that the young pharmacist Dale Tarapacki, who like my brother was burned to death in a suspicious truck fire in Great Valley, N.Y., also allegedly left a suicide letter.  This post adds further information about these two alleged suicide letters.

In a telephone conversation with N.Y.S.P. Captain Steven Nigrelli in 2014, I raised the problem of inconsistencies about an alleged suicide letter left by my brother (see post of March 31, 2019). Specifically, I brought up the following: the claim made to me by my brother’s daughter Christie the night of Mark’s death that he had left her a suicide letter, which she subsequently denied to the State Police investigator; the denial of a suicide letter by my brother’s wife Susan to the State Police investigator; and the report of a much later claim by Susan that Mark had in fact left a suicide letter.  Capt. Nigrelli responded by insisting that family members often deny the existence of a suicide letter in order to protect the insurance money but later admit it.  His explanation, however, did not take into account why Christie would have made the claim of a suicide letter to me at all.

Moreover, in his effort to justify the inconsistencies of those claims about a suicide letter, Capt. Nigrelli referred to Mark’s death as “autoerotic.”  In the circumstances of my brother’s death such a claim, implying an effort by the victim to achieve sexual gratification, makes no sense.  Autoerotic deaths are not very common in the U.S., and the majority of cases involve asphyxiation by hanging or ligature (see A. Sauvageau and S. Racette, “Autoerotic Deaths in the Literature from 1954 to 2004: A Review,” Journal of Forensic Sciences 51, 2006, 140-46).  Furthermore, autoerotic deaths are by nature unintentional; they are accidents, not the result of suicide.

That bizarre explanation by a New York State Police official also failed to account for the wounds on my brother’s head.  Two emergency workers on the scene of Mark’s truck fire and his attending physician at the burn unit observed a wound to his forehead, and a CT scan, according to Mark’s attending physician, revealed further soft-tissue damage to the left side of his face (see esp. post of January 29, 2019).  Capt. Nigrelli’s attempt to justify the failure of the State Police investigation to pursue the problematic claim of a suicide letter is simply ludicrous.

In Dale Tarapacki’s case, in addition to the reference to a suicide letter by two individuals, an entry in the police report by the Cattaraugus County Sheriff’s Department dated 4/11/05 (the day of Tarapacki's truck fire) summarizes the results of a search of Tarapacki’s house.  The relevant section concerning an apparent suicide letter reads as follows: “Sheriff John found a note apparently hand written by Dale Tarapacki which made mention that Tarapacki would be in a mind state of hurting himself.”

The language referring to this note is imprecise and unclear (see post of May 31, 2018).  Did officials check to determine if this note was actually rather than merely “apparently” written by Tarapacki?  What does the vague phrase “would be in a mind state of hurting himself” mean?  Why doesn’t the police report actually cite the specific language in that note found by Sheriff John?  An individual who knew Tarapacki well reported that far from intending to take his own life, shortly before his death Tarapacki feared for his safety.

Tarapacki as a pharmacist knew—and actually told an acquaintance—that there were peaceful ways of ending one’s life.  His actual death in the truck fire that burned his body beyond recognition hardly represents a “peaceful” way out.  Finally, the bullet wound to the rear side of his right thigh clearly wasn’t inflicted by Tarapacki himself and couldn’t have hit him accidentally as he sat in the driver’s seat of his truck.  How is it that the Sheriff’s investigators apparently never considered foul play in Tarapacki’s death?