This post considers how thoroughly the New York State Police examined my brother’s medical records after they obtained them in 2005 and what they learned from those records. In September 2005, Atty. Michael Kelly spoke in person with Senior Investigator John Wolfe and Edward Kalfas, the lead investigator in Mark’s case, in part to discuss information that had been reported to me by Mark’s attending physician at the burn unit and to Kelly by a firefighter on the scene. Wolfe then agreed to get Mark’s medical records.
As Kelly informed me, during that interview Wolfe instructed Kalfas to ask Mark’s wife Susan to sign a release for his medical records. In October, I called Wolfe to ask if he had obtained the medical records. He replied that he had not and that Susan Pavlock had not returned his call. He added that he would go directly to her place of employment and ask her in person to sign off on the medical records. When I next spoke with Wolfe, however, he stated that they had to subpoena the medical records.
In late December, Wolfe told me that he had received the medical records but could find nothing in them to indicate that my brother had been attacked. A few days later, Kelly informed me that he had just heard from Wolfe, who stated that he could find nothing in the medical records to warrant re-opening the case. Wolfe claimed that the soft-tissue damage was “positional” and not caused by an attack. Although Kelly himself told Wolfe that the wound could certainly have been the result of an attack, Wolfe insisted on his “positional” theory.
It seems ludicrous to assume that my brother’s forehead head was injured when emergency workers put him into the ambulance. In addition, Wolfe seemed oblivious to the fact (previously reported to him) that firefighter Wayne Frank saw the wound on Mark’s forehead when he was lying in the field the night of the fire and thought that someone had hit my brother with a golf club.
Wolfe insisted to Kelly that he had not seen anything in the medical records to confirm what my brother’s attending physician Edward Piotrowski had told me about soft-tissue damage to Mark’s forehead and to the left of his face (on the head wounds, see most recently post of January 29, 2019). Yet Wolfe’s own mention of soft-tissue damage to Mark’s head suggests that he may well have read some reference to it in the medical records.
According to Kelly, Wolfe could not say much about the medical records because they had been obtained through a subpoena. It is thus unfortunate that Wolfe had to get the records through a subpoena rather than through a release signed by my brother’s wife. In the latter case, he could presumably have allowed Kelly access to review them. Wolfe himself had told me that the records consisted of around sixty pages, much of them in a doctor's handwriting, and therefore he could not be sure that there was nothing about the soft-tissue swelling. Dr. Piotrowski, however, was very clear in his statements to me about the soft-tissue damage to Mark’s forehead and to the left side of his face.
After contacting numerous officials in New York State to get some meaningful answers about the investigation into my brother’s death, in April 2007 I was finally contacted by N.Y.S.P. Lieutenant Allen. That official, however, offered no clarification of the issues. He insisted, for instance, that there was only a small cut on the bridge of Mark’s nose. By contrast, two emergency workers on the scene saw the wound on my brother’s forehead, just where his attending physician at the burn unit observed soft-tissue swelling. According to the doctor, a CT scan showed the soft-tissue swelling to be of a deep, rather than a surface, nature. Lt. Allen also acknowledged that they had not looked at the CT scan.
Did the New York State Police make any serious effort to go through Mark’s medical records? It would appear that they did not.
Tuesday, March 31, 2020
Saturday, February 29, 2020
The Problem of My Brother’s Whereabouts Shortly before His Truck Fire
This post considers further the issue of where my brother Mark was shortly before a pool of his blood ended up in his driveway and his truck went up in flames in the field across from his house in rural Great Valley, N.Y., on September 23, 2003 (see posts of August 22, 2012, and March 3, 2014).
When I spoke with acquaintances of Mark’s in the weeks after his death, no one seemed to have any idea about his whereabouts the entire day of the fire. In conversations with me by phone and at one point in person, the N.Y. State Police investigator Edward Kalfas was not forthcoming with information and apparently was not pleased that I had made some inquiries of my own. He simply insisted that it looked like a suicide, but offered only the flimsiest of explanations for that view (see esp. post of March 27, 2012).
In an interview with Atty. Michael Kelly in September 2005, Kalfas acknowledged that he had not found anyone who saw Mark out the day of the fire. Mark’s wife Susan says in her witness statement that he was at home that day but left around 8:45 p.m. (Kalfas’s entry in the police report for September 25, 2003, that members of the Holy Cross Athletic Club commented that Mark “was very upset at getting arrested for DWI the day before the fire,” was presumably a careless error. Mark clearly did not go back to that club in the evening after his DWI, and Kalfas did not learn of anyone who saw him out the next day.)
According to an anonymous letter sent to me (see post of August 11, 2014), just before the fire Mark was at the house of a neighbor, who insisted that he could not have had as high a blood alcohol level as was reported (on the problem of the blood alcohol level, see posts of September 1, September 23, and October 29, 2013). Although a neighbor thus privately acknowledged being with Mark not long before the fire, that person presumably had not come forward during the investigation (nor had spoken publicly about it later) to provide an assessment, based on direct observation, of Mark’s physical and mental state the night of the fire.
Someone who knew my brother well informed me that Mark presumably would not have gone to visit anyone on Whelan Road that evening. My brother was certainly not at the home of EMT Cheryl Simcox around the corner on Cross Road (see Cheryl Simcox’s witness statement). Others on that street as well do not seem to have been likely candidates for a late-evening visit.
The broader neighborhood, however, included Mark’s friends Todd Lindell, Sidney Lindell, and Alexis and Jim Wright. According to Alexis, Jim had tried unsuccessfully to reach my brother by phone earlier that day, and then they drove by his house around 5:30 but did not go in (see post of September 29, 2019). Sidney Lindell told me that he assumed Mark would have been embarrassed about his DWI.
Todd Lindell stated that on the day before the truck fire my brother was at his house well into the evening after Todd retrieved Mark’s truck from the impoundment. In addition, Todd mentioned that that he had seen my brother on a daily basis for years and had an "open door" policy for him. Did Mark take advantage of that “open door” the evening of his truck fire? Todd also made the suggestive comment: “Mark would be alive today if he had not gotten the DWI." Yet he did not return my call when I tried to contact him again, even though he had stated that he would be happy to talk to me any time (see also posts of August 14, 2015, and December 31, 2017).
In small towns, privacy is a scarce commodity; everyone seems to know everyone else’s business. Later in the fall of 2003, my brother’s son Brian called, informing me that the autopsy report was out and that it ruled Mark’s death “an accident.” Puzzled that a determination was made while a police investigation was still ongoing, I asked about the Medical Examiner’s explanation. Stating that there wasn’t one, Brian offered to send me a copy of the report. He also asserted, “My mother heard that you have been talking to people around Salamanca about Mark's death.”
It took time to learn the identity of some individuals who were on the scene and to find out where some lived. A number of years after my brother’s death, I located one of them, who expressed surprise that I had not been in contact sooner and observed, “You’ve talked to everybody else.” Small towns talk.
Was it small-town pressure that kept the person whom Mark visited shortly before he was burned to death from coming forward?
Friday, January 31, 2020
Problematic Police Behavior in the Investigation into My Brother's Death
This post discusses problematic behavior by the New York State Police investigator related to certain insurance issues in the case of my brother Mark’s death.
Some time after Mark’s truck fire, it was relayed to me that his auto insurance company was concerned about the circumstances of the fire and was holding back on paying out for his truck. Although I did not know then with what company Mark had insured the truck, after obtaining the police report through a FOIL request in September 2004, I learned that Nationwide was the insurer. When I contacted the company later in September to find out about their concerns, a Nationwide agent mentioned that they had paid out on the policy for the truck but not on a second policy for medical bills.
Another agent then informed me that they were going to arbitration with Mark’s wife Susan over the medical bills. According to the agent, they had determined on the basis of their own investigation that the fire was not an accident. Among other things I had learned from the police report, I mentioned the pool of my brother’s blood found in his driveway the night of the fire. Expressing surprise at this information, the agent stated that the lead investigator, Edward Kalfas, had not revealed anything about blood found on the scene. The agent added that Kalfas also would not let Nationwide see the police report. After that conversation, I sent the police report to the Nationwide agent.
Inv. Kalfas’s failure to inform the insurance company about the pool of Mark’s blood is troubling. Withholding that information prevented Nationwide from making a fully informed determination about the cause of the truck fire. Since the police report does not mention the wound on Mark’s forehead, which I learned about first in 2005 from my brother’s attending physician at the burn unit and later from two fire fighters (see most recently post of January 29, 2019), Nationwide certainly did not have the full facts they needed to make a sound and accurate judgment about the fire.
When I brought up this issue with Buffalo criminal attorney Michael Kelly in 2005, he stated that Kalfas should have let Nationwide know about the pool of blood. The Nationwide agent had informed me that they were maintaining the position that Mark’s death was a suicide because of comments made off the record to their investigator and because of the heavily redacted nature of the police report, which made the case difficult to assess accurately. At the end of the arbitration process, the agent reported that they did not have to pay the medical bills, which were made the responsibility of another company.
Why did Inv. Kalfas withhold such important information about my brother’s truck fire that certainly did not point to an accident or a suicide? Who made the comments “off the record” that suggested a suicide? In spite of numerous suspicious facts (esp. Mark’s blood on the driveway, the wound on his forehead, and the gas can in the cab of the truck), my brother’s death was ultimately declared an accident by then District Attorney Edward Sharkey. However, the New York State Police continued to insist that they thought it a suicide (see most recently post of November 30, 2019).
Did Kalfas not only withhold significant information from Nationwide but also suggest to their investigator “off the record” that Mark had committed suicide? According to Mark’s and my half-sister, Susan told her that Kalfas had helped her with an insurance issue by talking directly to the representative of an insurance company. Did that help also involve withholding information about the blood in the driveway from Nationwide and any other insurance company concerned with Mark’s death?
Some time after Mark’s truck fire, it was relayed to me that his auto insurance company was concerned about the circumstances of the fire and was holding back on paying out for his truck. Although I did not know then with what company Mark had insured the truck, after obtaining the police report through a FOIL request in September 2004, I learned that Nationwide was the insurer. When I contacted the company later in September to find out about their concerns, a Nationwide agent mentioned that they had paid out on the policy for the truck but not on a second policy for medical bills.
Another agent then informed me that they were going to arbitration with Mark’s wife Susan over the medical bills. According to the agent, they had determined on the basis of their own investigation that the fire was not an accident. Among other things I had learned from the police report, I mentioned the pool of my brother’s blood found in his driveway the night of the fire. Expressing surprise at this information, the agent stated that the lead investigator, Edward Kalfas, had not revealed anything about blood found on the scene. The agent added that Kalfas also would not let Nationwide see the police report. After that conversation, I sent the police report to the Nationwide agent.
Inv. Kalfas’s failure to inform the insurance company about the pool of Mark’s blood is troubling. Withholding that information prevented Nationwide from making a fully informed determination about the cause of the truck fire. Since the police report does not mention the wound on Mark’s forehead, which I learned about first in 2005 from my brother’s attending physician at the burn unit and later from two fire fighters (see most recently post of January 29, 2019), Nationwide certainly did not have the full facts they needed to make a sound and accurate judgment about the fire.
When I brought up this issue with Buffalo criminal attorney Michael Kelly in 2005, he stated that Kalfas should have let Nationwide know about the pool of blood. The Nationwide agent had informed me that they were maintaining the position that Mark’s death was a suicide because of comments made off the record to their investigator and because of the heavily redacted nature of the police report, which made the case difficult to assess accurately. At the end of the arbitration process, the agent reported that they did not have to pay the medical bills, which were made the responsibility of another company.
Why did Inv. Kalfas withhold such important information about my brother’s truck fire that certainly did not point to an accident or a suicide? Who made the comments “off the record” that suggested a suicide? In spite of numerous suspicious facts (esp. Mark’s blood on the driveway, the wound on his forehead, and the gas can in the cab of the truck), my brother’s death was ultimately declared an accident by then District Attorney Edward Sharkey. However, the New York State Police continued to insist that they thought it a suicide (see most recently post of November 30, 2019).
Did Kalfas not only withhold significant information from Nationwide but also suggest to their investigator “off the record” that Mark had committed suicide? According to Mark’s and my half-sister, Susan told her that Kalfas had helped her with an insurance issue by talking directly to the representative of an insurance company. Did that help also involve withholding information about the blood in the driveway from Nationwide and any other insurance company concerned with Mark’s death?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)