Tuesday, October 25, 2016

The Importance of the Phone Records



This post considers the importance of the phone records as a source of relevant information in the death not only of my brother Mark but also of Dale Tarapacki and Tim Nye, the other two men who also were killed under very suspicious circumstances in Great Valley, N. Y., in the same general period.

A previous post (December 27, 2012) pointed to three crucial reasons why the phone records (landline and cell) should have been examined by the New York State Police in their investigation into Mark’s death: the argument between my brother and Salamanca police officer Mark Marowski at a local club that led to Marowski getting my brother arrested for DWI the very day before the truck fire; the alleged phone call between my brother’s wife Susan and Pete Rapacioli for about half an hour immediately prior to the fire; and problems with the chronology of events given by Mark’s wife both in her witness statement and, according to reliable sources, shortly after the fire. 

Since that post, I obtained further information reinforcing the importance of the phone records.  Although one State Police official claimed that “it wasn’t much of an argument,” the State Police investigator admitted that he never interviewed the club members present about the quarrel.  However, more than one person from the Salamanca area said that it had involved Marowski’s anger over a pool my brother had won that day.  An individual who had an official role at the Holy Cross Club at that time later informed me that my brother and Mark Marowski had argued on numerous occasions specifically over pool tabs, adding that people would often win a fair amount of money when there were only a few left to be sold, with winning tabs still to be drawn. 

In addition, as mentioned in a previous post (August 11, 2014), Marowski—now deceased—was reportedly having an affair with my brother’s wife during that period.  In spite of the fact that no one has publicly admitted to witnessing the argument between my brother and Marowski (which took place in the afternoon of Monday, September 22, 2003), a reliable source informed me that Gary Subulski and Pete Rapacioli were regularly there on Monday afternoons to sign the book.  Furthermore, a woman who answered Rapacioli’s phone when I called in early November 2003 (at the suggestion of a friend of Mark’s) informed me that Pete had told her about the argument between my brother and Marowski (see post of June 21, 2016).  Yet Rapacioli himself later claimed to me that he had not been there and appeared to know nothing about that argument (see post of June 23, 2013).

It seems clear that the phone records associated with my brother and his wife, with Mark Marowski, and with Pete Rapacioli should have been checked.  But they never were, either during the investigation or afterward, in spite of requests to the New York State Police in 2005 by Atty. Michael Kelly and me that they be examined.

In the case of Dale Tarapacki, as mentioned in previous posts (see March 19 and May 19, 2016), it is difficult to accept the explanation in the fire investigator’s report for the rear drive shaft breaking and puncturing the fuel line and for Tarapacki’s supposed efforts to accelerate aggressively, causing the wheels to spin excessively and the wheel bearings to fly off.  Furthermore, reports of a gunshot wound in the area of his right leg make the ruling of accident seem even less probable.  In addition, the remote location where Tarapacki’s truck was found (off the upper, unpaved section of Hardscrabble Road in Great Valley) raises the question of what Tarapacki would have been doing there.  Did the investigators from the Sheriff’s office look into this? 

It is also difficult to understand why Tarapacki’s death certificate indicates that he was a pharmacist at Rite Aid.  In fact, according to several reliable sources, he had resigned from that job and accepted a position at a new Native American-owned pharmacy, also in Salamanca, reportedly for a much higher salary.  However, according to my sources, he had issues concerning that job and quit, reportedly after about a month.  Did the investigators consider why Tarapacki had abruptly left that job?

A reliable source expressed concern about how quickly the investigation into Tarapacki’s death concluded.  It would appear that the investigators did not check Tarapacki’s phone records.  The phone records certainly might have revealed if Tarapacki had been called by someone just prior to that very odd drive up Hardscrabble Road.

Finally, although much less information has been given to me about the case of Tim Nye (see posts of February 18, March 19, and April 19, 2016), one fact in particular should have motivated the investigators from the Sheriff’s office to obtain his phone records.  As reported in the post of April 19 and an addendum to it, after he left his residence following a phone call that appeared to cause him considerable anxiety, no one heard from Tim Nye for two days, and he strangely did not return phone calls during those two days. 

This would appear to be a case where the phone records were essential.  The investigators should certainly have wanted to know who had called him and to learn what that person’s conversation with Nye had been about.  But here as well, it appears that phone records were never checked.  A relative of his confirmed to me that Nye had been shot in the gut.  Yet, according to another source very close to Nye, his death was ruled a suicide.

Saturday, September 24, 2016

The Issue of Head Wounds


Thirteen years ago today, my brother Mark died from severe burns suffered the night of his truck fire in rural Great Valley, New York.  As the years have passed and more information has come to light, the cover-up of the foul play that took Mark’s life has made me seriously question our justice system.  Some of the information that has come to my attention most recently relates to troublesome similarities between the circumstances of my brother’s death and Dale Tarapacki’s (see esp. the posts of July 23 and August 24, 2016).  This post concerns head wounds as another factor linking the two deaths.

As reported in the initial post (September 22, 2010), Dr. Edward Piotrowski, Mark’s attending physician at the Erie County Medical Center, informed me in 2005 that when my brother arrived at the burn unit, he observed soft-tissue swelling on Mark’s forehead.  In order to determine if there was bleeding in his brain, Dr. Piotrowski ordered a CT scan.  The results of the scan concerned the doctor: although no bleeding was detected, there was deep, rather than superficial, soft-tissue swelling that made him think my brother might have been struck on the head.

When this information was relayed to the New York State Police investigators, they dismissed it, claiming that Mark had probably fallen and hit his head.  But, in addition, Dr. Piotrowski had revealed that Mark had also suffered soft-tissue swelling on the left side of his face and explained that my brother would have had to fall several times to get that level of soft-tissue damage.  The State Police never interviewed Dr. Piotrowski about these wounds or anything else he had observed in the burn unit related to my brother’s condition.

The State Police were also informed that firefighter Wayne Frank, who helped put the flames out on Mark, had noticed the wound on his forehead.  That wound was small but apparently well defined; by the time Mark arrived at the burn unit, it had obviously developed the swelling that so concerned Dr. Piotrowski.  To Wayne, it looked as if Mark had been hit on the head with a golf club.  Although the State Police said that they would interview Wayne, they apparently never did.  Gary Wind, a Deputy Sheriff and the first firefighter on the scene of the truck fire, later told me that he too had seen the wound on Mark’s forehead.  It is odd that the presence of the wound never made it into the official records on the truck fire.

Earlier posts (see esp. May 29 and September 22, 2012) discussed the facts indicating the following: my brother was beaten up after he pulled into his driveway and parked his truck; someone other than Mark backed his truck into the field across from his house; gasoline was poured in the front seat area of his pick-up truck; Mark himself was also doused with gasoline and set on fire.

It has been a matter of concern that the fire investigator’s report does not mention a pistol among the items found in the truck or on the scene.  According to a friend of his, my brother had bought a pistol because he had concerns for his safety at his job at M&M’s, a Native American cigarette store and gas station, where Mark had recently become a security guard.  Since the location is close to an off ramp of I-86 at Steamburg, N.Y., it is not clear why he felt anxious about his safety there.  At any rate, Mark reportedly kept the gun in the glove compartment of his truck. So what happened to it? Could it have been used to hit him on the forehead, and was it then taken away by his assailant (or, more likely, assailants)?

Dale Tarapacki’s death certificate does not mention impact wounds but rather states the cause of death as “acute alprazolam intoxication complicated by inhalation of products of combustion and thermal injury” (see post of May 19, 2016).  According to reliable sources, Tarapacki, who not long before his death had resigned his job as a pharmacist at the Rite-Aid in Salamanca to work for a new Native-American pharmacy there, had expressed concerns about his own safety.  As discussed in recent posts (May 19, July 23, and August 24, 2016), Tarapacki died in a truck fire under very suspicious circumstances just as Mark had.

It was previously mentioned that Tarapacki reportedly had a gunshot wound in the area of his right leg (see July 23, 2016).  Furthermore, a reliable source recently informed me that, according to a police official at the time of his death, Tarapacki had also suffered a serious head injury (apparently a cracked skull).  As reliable sources have also mentioned, the remains of two rifles were found in the rear of the cab of Tarapacki’s burned-out truck.  Had one of them also been used to strike him on the head and render him unconscious?

The similarities between my brother’s death and Tarapacki’s seem too numerous to be coincidental, especially for what authorities claimed in each case was an “accident.”




Wednesday, August 24, 2016

The Problem of Toxic Substances Revisited


This post concerns the disturbing issue of toxic levels of an ingested substance in the post-mortem medical findings for both my brother Mark and Dale Tarapacki.

As reported in previous posts (see esp. September 1, September 23, and October 29, 2013), my brother’s autopsy report records a post-mortem .25 serum alcohol level: that post-mortem reading means that Mark would have had a blood alcohol level of approximately .46 at the time of his truck fire.  That extraordinarily high blood alcohol level has always seemed impossible for the following reasons:

(1) My brother would almost certainly have been in a coma, if not actually dead, from that level of alcohol before the truck fire ever occurred (see post of September 1, 2013).

(2) Then Erie County Medical Examiner Sung-ook Baik, according to Atty. Michael Kelly who expressed his concerns about this issue, agreed that the post-mortem reading seemed too high, though he accepted what the lab technicians had given him (see post of September 1, 2013).

(3) It would also have been completely out of character for my brother to risk another DWI, after being arrested for DWI following a personal argument with off-duty policeman Mark Marowski the day before his truck fire.  In fact, Mark had told two different friends shortly after his arrest for DWI that he would be careful, since he needed to drive to his job as a security guard (see post of September 23, 2013).

(4) Most tellingly, the writer of the anonymous letter sent to me (see post of August 11, 2014) stated emphatically that Mark had been at a neighbor’s house right before his truck fire and that this neighbor insisted that my brother could not possibly have had a blood alcohol level of .25 (much less .46!).  Unfortunately, neither the writer of the anonymous letter nor the neighbor whom Mark visited just before the fire has come forward.

According to an addendum in Dale Tarapacki’s death certificate, Tarapacki died as a result of “acute alprazolam intoxication complicated by inhalation of products of combustion and thermal injury.”  A previous post (May 19, 2016) brought up the cause of death in order to raise a problem about the explanation for the truck fire in the fire investigator’s report: it is difficult to comprehend how Tarapacki himself caused the truck fire and remained in the truck long enough to inhale the deadly smoke of the fire (“products of combustion”) and suffer fatal burns (“thermal injury”).

However, a reliable source recently informed me that a police search of Tarapacki’s house did not turn up any prescription drugs such as alprazolam.  That lack raises a serious question: if an individual was taking a drug like alprazolam at such a high level, wouldn’t there be some evidence of that substance at the person’s residence?

Saturday, July 23, 2016

Similarities in the Suspicious Deaths of My Brother and Dale Tarapacki

Numerous posts have highlighted the suspicious elements of my brother Mark's truck fire (see especially June 26 and November 30, 2011; May 29, July 22, August 22, September 22, and November 1, 2012; May 15 and November 23, 2013; and August 14, 2015).  Two previous posts discuss problems related to the official explanation for the cause of Dale Tarapacki's truck fire, as recorded in the fire investigator's report (see post of March 19, 2016), and for his death, as recorded in the autopsy report (see May 19, 2016).  Expanding on some of those issues, this post shows that the similarities between Tarapacki's death and my brother's point to foul play in both cases.

Both my brother and Dale Tarapacki were severely burned in truck fires that originated under very suspicious circumstances.  There is no reasonable way to account either for the location of Mark's truck fifty feet into the field across the road from his house in rural Great Valley or for the presence of the gas can in the cab of his truck.  Although within hours after the fire, according to at least one relative, his wife said that Mark had been putting gas into the tank because it had run out of gas, the tank was in fact three-quarters full (see post of September 22, 2012).  As numerous friends of his insisted, Mark also never put gas cans into the cab but rather only into the back of his truck.  It is hard to comprehend how Mark himself got saturated with gasoline, how a flammable liquid, presumably gasoline, was spilled in the driver's seat area, and how the fire then started from that source.

In Dale Tarapacki's case, the truck was found in an oddly remote location off the upper, unpaved section of Hardscrabble Road in Great Valley.  It is very difficult to comprehend what Tarapacki would have been doing there and how his truck would have got stuck off the road.  As to the cause of his truck fire, even an experienced car mechanic found it difficult to comprehend the official explanation as stated in the fire investigator's report.  In particular, the mechanic noted that it is hard for a drive shaft to puncture the fuel line, and the wheel bearings would take a long time to fly off (see March 19, 2016).  Recently, another individual added additional information that further calls the official explanation for the Tarapacki fire into question.  As I was informed, Tarapacki had had his truck skid-plated from front to back and off-road tires installed.  According to my source, Tarapacki's truck was so well protected that the explanation of the damage as accidental in the fire investigator's report could not be true.

When first responders arrived on the scene of both truck fires, my brother and Dale Tarapacki were found not only to have been very seriously burned but also to have been inflicted with other kinds of injuries.  In Mark's case, a wound was observed on his forehead that made firefighter Wayne Frank think someone had hit him with a golf club.  Dr. Edward Piotrowski, Mark's attending physician at the burn unit, told me that he had been concerned about soft tissue swelling on my brother's forehead and ordered a CT scan.  It revealed deep soft-tissue swelling that made the doctor wonder if Mark had been hit over the head (see post of September 22, 2010).

According to more than one reliable source, Tarapacki had a gunshot wound in the area of his right leg.  As these sources also indicated, the investigating authorities (the Sheriff's office) claimed that Tarapacki had been accidentally shot because the extreme heat of the truck fire caused the guns to go off.  Yet, as more than one individual insisted, it does not seem possible that either of the two rifles in the back area of the cab could have hit Tarapacki in the leg while he sat in the driver's seat, where his body was reportedly found.

This post by no means exhausts the similarities in the suspicious nature of both my brother's and Dale Tarapacki's deaths.  But, by itself, the information here suggests deeply flawed investigations that appear to have been covering up, rather than searching for, the truth.  In my brother's case, the State Police investigation clearly protected Salamanca police officer Mark Marowski, who the day before the truck fire, got into a personal argument with my brother at a local club and called in to have him arrested for DWI.  As I learned much later, Marowski was also reportedly having an affair with my brother's wife (see post of August 11, 2014).  Not long ago, I was informed by a reliable source that Dale Tarapacki had also got a DWI not long before his suspicious death.  I do not know the details of that arrest.  Did someone call in to the police to pick him up as well?  Like Mark, Tarapacki is known to have frequented the Holy Cross Club.

All of this information makes one wonder how wide the net is of people who were protected in the investigations into both Mark's and Tarapacki's death and why they were protected.  In my brother's case, Marowski presumably was automatically protected because he was a police officer.  But Marowski was also known to have long been abusing prescription drugs.  According to a fellow police officer who worked with him in the 1970's, Marowski had a problem with prescription drugs even back then (see post of September 13, 2015).  David Marowski recently informed me that around 1990 he was called to a local hospital when his brother Mark was being treated for injuries reportedly caused by a fall and was asked by hospital personnel if his brother had any problems with substance or alcohol abuse.  David informed them about Marowski's use of Valium as well as his long-time heavy drinking (“since probably 10th grade,” as David put it to me).  Clearly, no reputable doctor would have been prescribing drugs to satisfy an addiction.  Marowski presumably got at least some of these drugs illegally.

Reports about other local policemen using drugs illegally are a matter of concern about who gets protected when crimes are committed.  One individual informed me about an incident that took place when he happened to be at the house of a Salamanca area police officer within the time frame of Mark's and Tarapacki's deaths.  According to my source, the police officer told him, “Pick your poison: marijuana, cocaine, heroine.  This is the stuff that didn't get turned in.”

Tuesday, June 21, 2016

More on Mark Marowski and the Argument at the Holy Cross Club

Several previous posts (see esp. posts of July 28, 2011, April 18, 2013, September 14, 2014, October 17, 2014, and July 15, 2015) have raised the problem of the argument between my brother and then Salamanca police officer Mark Marowski.  That quarrel, resulting in a DWI for Mark, happened the very day before the suspicious truck fire that took his life.  Yet the New York State Police did not interview Holy Cross Club members who witnessed the argument and did not press Marowski himself about the argument.  In addition, it is troubling that Holy Cross Club members have been unwilling to admit to being present at the time of the argument, even though numerous individuals mentioned details about the altercation and about Marowski's behavior shortly after my brother's death.

It is very odd that not one person will admit to being at the Holy Cross Club at the time of the argument between Marowski and my brother (see esp. post of November 16, 2014).  However, two specific individuals, according to a reliable source, were regularly there on Monday afternoons to sign the Monday book.  They were Pete Rapacioli and Gary Subulski.  Both of these men adamantly denied to me that they were there (see post of July 15, 2015).  Yet not long after Mark's death, my cousin Dennis Pavlock said that the information he had about that argument came from Gary Subulski, who gave Dennis the strong impression that he had been there.  When I called to speak with Pete Rapacioli shortly after Mark's death, the woman who answered his phone mentioned that Pete had told her about the argument, and Pete's cousin (and long-time friend of my brother) Jack Plonka told me that Pete had told a neighbor of Jack's mother about the argument.

Given their regular presence there on Monday afternoons, it seems unlikely that both of these men were absent from the Holy Cross Club that particular day, when my brother got into the argument with Marowski.  Rapacioli himself is problematic because of his alleged phone call with my brother's wife Susan for around half an hour immediately before the truck fire.  The State Police failed to verify that alleged phone call during the investigation by checking the phone records and later refused to verify the call when asked to do so by Atty. Michael Kelly even though they initially said they would.  Rapacioli reportedly was friendly with Marowski.  Gary Subulski has known Marowski since elementary school, though it is not clear if they were friendly, but he has certainly been on good terms with Rapacioli, a former fellow railroader.  Gary, who had previously encouraged me to continue to pursue justice for my brother, abruptly hung up the phone on me when I called to ask him a question about Pete Rapacioli.

As specific information about Marowski has become known (see esp. posts of September 14, 2014, October 17, 2014, November 16, 2014, December 14, 2014, February 17, 2015, July 15, 2015, and September 13, 2015), the failure of the State Police to investigate the argument between my brother and Marowski has become more troublesome.  The most salient points about Marowski include (1) his obvious hostility to my brother, evidenced by reportedly numerous quarrels with him at the Holy Cross Club and by his reported boasting about calling in to have Mark arrested for DWI, despite the fact that my brother suffered third-degree burns over most his body; (2) his alleged affair with my brother's wife; (3) his reported physical abuse of women with whom he lived; (4) his frequent failure to pay back money he owed, resulting in lawsuits against him by numerous individuals; (5) his reported gambling problem; (6) his reported dependence on prescription drugs; and (7) his very heavy drinking, reportedly affecting his performance as a police officer and culminating in a DWI, for which he was suspended from the Salamanca police department and forced to retire.

If generally “reported” comments about Marowski's disgraceful behavior may not seem compelling, remarks by a close family member of his make a strong impact.  Having seen my blog, David Marowski, a classmate of mine from Holy Cross elementary school through Salamanca high school, recently sent me an e-mail with his own personal reflections on his brother. It should be noted that David not only sent me his thoughts of his own accord but also gave me permission to quote them here.  David made it clear that he has nothing to do with Mark Marowski.  Here is what he had to say: “Although, as far as I know, we only live about 30 miles apart, I haven't seen him since my mother's death in 1991 (ZERO CONTACT). At my mother's funeral, he kept a low profile.  I ended up paying the funeral expenses; he didn't even put a flower on her grave.”  David went on to explain his reasons for distancing himself completely from his own brother, as follows: Mark “has never been trustworthy.  He has been a liar as far back as High School....We have found out that he has SCAMMED a lot of people and businesses. He SCAMMED me out of any inheritance.  He is NOT a nice person.”

A comment made some time ago (November 2014) in a post on a website called “Cat County Corruption” that exposed my brother's suspicious death suggests in general terms why he may have been killed. Here is the relevant remark: “This man appears to have taken action when he saw something wrong, and this is what happened to him.”  The author of the post is anonymous, and the source of that provocative comment not disclosed.  If there is a basis for it, where might Mark have seen “something wrong”?  The logical venues would be his regular social hangout or his place of work.  An individual who frequented the Holy Cross Club in the period when Mark was killed mentioned that “things went on there behind the scenes.”  Could my brother have seen something inappropriate or illegal going on there?

Given the almost uncanny silence of the Holy Cross Club members about the argument between my brother and Mark Marowski, those who were there that afternoon must have seen or heard something very disturbing to keep them from speaking out.  Whatever vicious impulse motivated someone to burn my brother to death, there are people out there who know the truth.  Has fear kept them thus far from coming forward?



Thursday, May 19, 2016

A Follow-up on a FOIL Request for Records on the Death of Dale Tarapacki

A previous post (March 19, 2016) reported on the inadequate response by Cattaraugus County to my FOIL request for records on the death of Dale Tarapacki.  As a number of individuals in the Salamanca area informed me, Mr. Tarapacki was one of two others who also died under suspicious circumstances in Great Valley, New York, within a year or so after my brother Mark was found engulfed in flames in the field across from his house in rural Great Valley.  His burning pickup truck was located about 60 feet away, with a gas can on the floor of the passenger's side--a very suspicious detail since my brother never put gas cans in the cab of his truck.  Dale Tarapacki also died as a result of a suspicious truck fire.  In his case, the official explanation for the truck fire, according to the fire investigator's report, appeared difficult to grasp even for an experienced mechanic, as the post of March 19 details.

Although my FOIL request for the official records related to Dale Tarapacki's death resulted in my receiving only the fire investigator's report, subsequently a private individual gave me access to his death certificate.  This post raises concerns about the combination of factors that the death certificate mentions as leading to Tarapacki's death.  Those factors include the truck fire itself.  According to an addendum (“corrected 7-1-05”), Tarapacki died as a result of “acute alprazolam intoxication complicated by inhalation of products of combustion and thermal injury.”  My intention here is not to challenge the medical explanation per se but rather to question how it happened that Tarapacki himself caused the truck fire and remained in the truck long enough to inhale the deadly smoke of the fire (“products of combustion”) and suffer fatal burns (“thermal injury”).

Alprazolam, a drug classified as a benzodiazepine and commonly prescribed under the brand name of Xanax, is used to treat anxiety and depression.  Someone who knew him well said that around the time of his death Tarapacki was feeling some anxiety, and according to widely known published information, the effects of excessive amounts of alprazolam can include drowsiness, confusion, and muscle weakness, among other symptoms.  But Tarapacki was a pharmacist, who would have known how much of that drug—or any other drug—would be dangerous to ingest.  He certainly would not have wanted to take his own life--or to risk it--under the particular circumstances in which he actually died.  Another friend of his who was suspicious of the truck fire reported that Tarapacki as a pharmacist had mentioned in conversation that there are peaceful ways to die.  His own manner of death was anything but “peaceful.”

Even if somehow he did carelessly overdose on alprazolam and suffer the likely symptoms, it is then difficult to grasp how he kept trying to accelerate the truck after it became stuck on remote Hardscrabble Road.  As the fire investigator's report suggests, Tarapacki had been alert enough to continue to accelerate in an aggressive manner, to no effect; he thus reportedly caused the wheels to spin excessively after the rear drive shaft broke and punctured the fuel line.  (See post of March 16, with a copy of the fire investigator's report: "The wheel bearings of the front passenger wheel were blown out of the housing as a result of the front drive shaft being engaged and under extreme RPM's during attempts by the driver to move the vehicle.")

The official explanation for Tarapacki's death seems, then, to raise more questions than it answers.



Tuesday, April 19, 2016

A Follow-up on a FOIL Request for Records on the Death of Tim Nye

A previous post (February 18, 2016) reported on the very inadequate response by Cattaraugus County to my FOIL request for records on the death of Tim Nye.  Mr. Nye was one of two individuals whose deaths, as I was informed by numerous individuals, occurred under suspicious circumstances in Great Valley, New York, within a year or so of my brother’s truck fire.  The other was a young pharmacist named Dale Tarapacki, whose body was found in his burned-out truck (on my FOIL request for the records on his death, see the post of March 19, 2016).

In violation of both the spirit and the letter of the New York State FOIA law whose purpose is “to promote open government and accountability,” Cattaraugus County initially refused to provide any records, including the police investigation report, even in a redacted form, and on appeal sent two scant pages, consisting of the “Incident Maintenance” sheet and the very brief report by the officer who discovered Nye’s body with a shotgun lying close by.  Merely reiterating the unacceptable claim that the requested documents were “intra-agency materials of the Sheriff’s Office,” Records Appeals Officer John Searles again denied me access to the police investigation report, even in redacted form.

Although I did not obtain the documents that my FOIL request should have provided, I have learned more information about Tim Nye’s death through other means.  I happened to speak with a relative of Tim Nye who provided some troubling information related to his death.  This individual informed me that on the day of his death, Tim received a phone call at dinner time and, appearing very anxious, said that he had to go out.  Tim Nye never returned home.  [Posted on April 27, 2016--The following adjustment has been made at the request of someone who claims to be a reliable source: After he left following the phone call, no one heard from Tim for two days, and he did not return phone calls during those two days, which was not like him.]

According to Tim’s relative, he had been shot in the gut, confirming what an EMT who knew Tim also told me.  Apparently, Tim had been heavily in debt.  His relative also informed me that at the time of his death Tim no longer lived on Hungry Hollow Road, as he had broken up with a girlfriend who owned a house there.  One must wonder, then, why Tim Nye was found shot to death on rural McCarthy Hill Road in Great Valley, as indicated in the report filed by the officer who found his body with a shotgun lying at his feet.  Tim’s relative stressed that his death was no suicide.

Because I was given no access to the police investigation report, I cannot say for sure what the official ruling was.  But according to virtually everyone who has mentioned Tim Nye’s death to me, the authorities ruled it a suicide.  However, the presumably reliable information relayed to me by Tim’s relative does not at all suggest a suicide.

How thorough was the investigation into Tim Nye’s death?  Was murder even considered?  There would appear to have been a rush to judgment by the investigating authorities similar to that which occurred in the case of my brother Mark’s suspicious death.  In my brother’s case, the authorities clearly did not want to expose any possible involvement by then Salamanca police officer Mark Marowski, who had got into a personal argument with my brother at a local club the day before his truck fire and then called in to the Salamanca police to have him arrested for DWI and who had allegedly been having an affair with my brother’s wife (see esp. posts of August 11, September 14, October 17, November 16, and December 14, 2014, and January 16 and February 17, 2015).  Did the police have something to cover up yet again in this case?

Saturday, March 19, 2016

Another FOIL Request to Cattaraugus County


The previous post (February 18, 2016) reported on the results of my FOIL request to Cattaraugus County for records on the death of Tim Nye. Mr. Nye was one of two individuals whose deaths, I was told, happened under suspicious circumstances in Great Valley, New York, within a year or so of my brother’s suspicious truck fire. In blatant violation of both the spirit and the letter of the New York State FOIA law, Cattaraugus County refused to provide any records, including the police investigation report, even in a redacted form. To my appeal of their denial of the records, Cattaraugus County sent two pages, consisting of a copy of the “Incident Maintenance” sheet and of the very brief report by the officer who discovered Nye’s body with a gun lying close by, but still denied me access to the police investigation report.

This post reports on the results of my FOIL request to Cattaraugus County for records on the death of Dale Tarapacki, a twenty-seven year old pharmacist whose body was found in his burned-out truck in Great Valley.

Since my initial FOIL request on Tim Nye met with an absolute refusal, it came as no real surprise that Cattaraugus County also denied me all records on Dale Tarapacki’s death. The explanation for the denial was essentially the same as that for the Nye records: “Pursuant to Public Officers Law [section] 87 (2) (a) the records requested are compiled for law enforcement purposes and are inter-agency materials.” However, as mentioned in my letter of appeal, the New York State courts have made it clear that “blanket exemptions for particular types of documents are inimical to FOIL’s policy of open government” and that “FOIL imposes a broad duty on government to make its records available to the public.”

As with my appeal in the Nye case, I soon received a response from Records Appeals Officer John Searles, this time with a copy of the fire investigator’s report on Dale Tarapacki’s death. But, once again, he denied access to the other records, which he added “consist of 11 pages of intra-agency investigation reports of the Cattaraugus County Sheriff’s Office.” As with the response to my appeal on the Nye records, I replied to Mr. Searles in a letter of February 10, 2016, stating that I considered his position unwarranted and in violation of the New York State FOIA law.

The fire investigator’s report provides information about the condition of Dale Tarapacki’s truck, which was discovered with his body inside, but it seems to raise more questions than it answers. (Copies of the fire investigator’s report, my FOIL request, my letter of appeal, and Mr. Searles’ response appear at the end of this post.) Without the police investigation report, it is impossible to understand what could have happened to bring that young man’s life to such an unfortunate end.

Having no basis myself for interpreting the analysis found on the second page of the fire investigator’s report, I asked an experienced car mechanic to look it over and give me his opinion. He certainly had questions about the explanation provided for Dale Tarapacki’s truck fire. Here are some major points of concern raised by the mechanic: (1) It is hard for a drive shaft to puncture the fuel line. The shaft in Tarapacki’s truck may have had a bad joint, but that is not a common occurrence. (2) A broken drive shaft makes a great deal of noise; Tarapacki thus would have been very aware of a major problem with the truck. (3) Gas lines are very well protected. (4) The spinning wheel bearings would have taken some time to blow out of the housing, and Tarapacki would have had the opportunity to get out of the truck.

At the end of the fire investigator’s report, the determination is made by the Sheriff’s Office that the truck fire was accidental. However, the broken drive shaft seems very puzzling. It simply raises too many questions that need to be answered. And Tarapacki himself seems to have had plenty of time to get out. So why was he found dead inside his truck?

To add to the puzzle of this case, a reliable source informed me that Dale Tarapacki’s death was ruled a suicide. But since I have been denied access to the police investigation report, it is impossible for me to verify what the final ruling was and on what grounds it was made.



Thursday, February 18, 2016

A FOIL Request to Cattaraugus County


A previous post (October 16, 2015) cited a comment from the Salamanca Topix site (dated May 2013) linking my brother’s death to others that happened around the same time under suspicious circumstances yet were apparently ruled suicides.  One of the individuals named in that Topix comment was Tim Nye.  As also mentioned in that same October blog post, I did not have any official information about the death of Tim Nye or the other individuals, including a young pharmacist named Dale Tarapacki, whose body was found in his burned-out truck, and therefore I could not make any assumptions about the investigations into their deaths.  But for several years various individuals in the Salamanca area, in referring to my brother’s truck fire, have brought up the deaths of Tim Nye and a Rite Aid pharmacist (Dale Tarapacki) as similarly suspicious incidents.  This post reports on my efforts to get information about Tim Nye’s death through a FOIL request for the official records.

Since I had obtained the investigation report and related documents, with redactions, on my brother’s death through a FOIL request to the New York State Police, I submitted a FOIL request to Cattaraugus County for the records on Mr. Nye.  To my complete surprise, my request was denied, with the explanation that “[r]ecords are compiled for law enforcement purposes and are inter-agency or intra-agency materials, not statistical or factual tabulations or data.”  The Cattaraugus County response merely restated the language of section 87 (2) (g) of the New York Public Officers Law.  But, logically, how could such official documents related to the death of Mr. Nye not contain factual data?  I appealed that decision, citing that the purpose of the Freedom of Information Law is “to promote open government and accountability” and that if a police report or any related document has any factual data, then that information has to be disclosed.

Soon afterward, I received a response from Records Appeals Officer John Searles, with two pages related to my request and with a reiteration that records “are compiled for inter-agency or intra-agency purposes.”  The two scant pages, however, contain very little information.  [They are posted below, along with my original FOIL request, my letter of  appeal, and Mr. Searles' letter of reply.]  Neither Mr. Nye’s name nor his address appears on either of these documents.  An internet search listed his address as 4445 Hungry Hollow Road in Great Valley.  If that is the case, then Tim Nye lived in the same neighborhood as my brother.  The date of the incident, as recorded in the documents sent to me by Mr. Searles, is September 2, 2004, which was less than a year after my brother’s death.  The first officer on the scene is listed as Andrew Rozler (a deputy sheriff, who, I was informed, lived on Cross Rd., close to my brother’s house).

The few factual statements provided are not very informative.  The “Incident Maintenance” sheet lists the location (i.e., of the discovery of the wounded Mr. Nye) as “Hungry Hollow Great Valley,” yet the other sheet, with a very brief narrative, states that “[p]atrol found above vehicle parked with the door open on McCarthy Hill Road in the Town of Great Valley.”  It is thus unclear where Tim Nye was actually found.  Was it near an intersection of Hungry Hollow and McCarthy Hill roads?  The following is the only information given about Mr. Nye himself: “After checking the scene, patrol found the victim laying [sic] on the ground with a shotgun laying [sic] next to his feet.  Victim had suffered an apparent gunshot wound.”  No mention is made concerning the location of the wound.  Although the penultimate sentence of this brief narrative states that the officer “requested an ambulance,” nothing further is indicated about Mr. Nye’s condition.  The sixth and final sentence is redacted.

I replied to Mr. Searles on January 20, 2016, that this was an unsatisfactory response to my FOIL appeal and that Cattaraugus County was required by the FOIA law to release all documents with factual information pertaining to the death of Timothy Nye.  He responded on January 27 with the same rationale as before, justifying the denial on the basis that the records “are intra-agency materials of the Sheriff’s Office” and adding the following: “Specifically, these records consist of nine pages of intra-agency investigation reports of the Cattaraugus County Sheriff’s Office.”  I sent a final letter to Mr. Searles on February 10 stating that I considered his position “completely unwarranted and in violation of the New York State FOIA law.”

Why should Cattaraugus County refuse to provide access to records that should, at least in part, be available to public scrutiny?  Are they trying to hide facts about suspicious deaths from the public?  How can they get away with such violations of the law?  As some individuals have suggested, officials know that people of modest incomes cannot afford to go through an expensive lawsuit to obtain records that should be available under FOIL.  But that does not speak well of our justice system.